- Alphabet of Nations#1 They Might Be Giants: Here Come the ABCsReplayed song
- I Never Go to Work (Seven Days of the Week)#2 Here Come the 123s
- Apartment Four#3 Here Come the 123s
- Particle Man#4 FloodReplayed song
- E Eats Everything#5 They Might Be Giants: Here Come the ABCs
- Seven#6 Here Come the 123sReplayed song
- No!#7 No! (Deluxe Edition)
- Clap Your Hands#8 They Might Be Giants: Here Come the ABCsReplayed song
- Alphabet Lost and Found#9 They Might Be Giants: Here Come the ABCs
- I Am Not Your Broom#10 No! (Deluxe Edition)
- Pirate Girls Nine#11 Here Come the 123s
- Doctor Worm#12 Severe Tire DamageReplayed song
- Older#13 Mink CarReplayed song
- Where Do They Make Balloons?#14 No! (Deluxe Edition)
- Birdhouse in Your Soul#15 FloodReplayed song
- Bed Bed Bed#16 No! (Deluxe Edition)
- Boss of Me#17 Mink Car
Graveyard#18 No AlbumReplayed song- Robot Parade#19 Mink Car
- Eight Hundred and Thirteen Mile Car Trip#20 Here Come the 123s
- Istanbul (Not Constantinople)#21 FloodThe Four Lads cover Replayed song
- Istanbul (Not Constantinople)#22 FloodThe Four Lads cover Replayed song
- Damn Good Times#23 The Spine
- Hey, Mr. DJ, I Thought You Said We Had a Deal#24 Then: The Earlier Years
- S-E-X-X-Y#25 Severe Tire Damage
- Drink!#26 Mink Car
- Particle Man#27 FloodReplayed song
- Wicked Little Critta#28 Mink Car
- Dinner Bell#29 Apollo 18
- Take Out the Trash#30 The Else
- Seven#31 Here Come the 123sReplayed song
- Clap Your Hands#32 They Might Be Giants: Here Come the ABCsReplayed song
- The Guitar (The Lion Sleeps Tonight)#33 Apollo 18
- Why Does the Sun Shine? (The Sun Is a Mass of Incandescent Gas)#34 Severe Tire DamageTom Glazer cover
- Withered Hope#35 The Else
- New York City#36 Factory Showroomcub cover
- Phone Calls from the Dead#37 No Album
- James K. Polk#38 Factory Showroom
- Memo to Human Resources#39 The Spine
- The Mesopotamians#40 The Else
- Older#41 Mink CarEncore 1 Replayed song
- Alphabet of Nations#42 They Might Be Giants: Here Come the ABCsEncore 1 Replayed song
- Graveyard#43 No AlbumEncore 1 Replayed song
- Birdhouse in Your Soul#44 FloodEncore 1 Replayed song
- Everything Is Catching on Fire#45 No AlbumEncore 2
- Fingertips#46 Apollo 18Encore 2
- I Hear the Wind Blow#47 No AlbumEncore 2
- Hey Now Everybody Now#48 No AlbumEncore 2
- Who’s That Standing Out My Window?#49 No AlbumEncore 2
- I Found a New Friend#50 No AlbumEncore 2
- Come On and Wreck My Car#51 No AlbumEncore 2
- Aren’t You the Guy Who Hit Me in the Eye?#52 No AlbumEncore 2
- Please Pass the Milk, Please#53 No AlbumEncore 2
- Leave Me Alone#54 No AlbumEncore 2
- Who’s Knocking on the Wall?#55 No AlbumEncore 2
- All Alone#56 They Got LostEncore 2
- What’s That Blue Thing Doing Here?#57 No AlbumEncore 2
- Something Grabbed Ahold of My Hand#58 No AlbumEncore 2
- I Don’t Understand You#59 No AlbumEncore 2
- I Heard a Sound#60 No AlbumEncore 2
- Mysterious Whisper#61 No AlbumEncore 2
- The Day That Love Came to Play#62 No AlbumEncore 2
- I'm Havin' a Heart Attack#63 No AlbumEncore 2
- Fingertips (Reprise)#64 No AlbumEncore 2
- I Walk Along Darkened Corridors#65 No AlbumEncore 2
- Doctor Worm#66 Severe Tire DamageEncore 2 Replayed song
Concert Resume
- Artist
- They Might Be Giants
- Covers
- cub, The Four Lads and Tom Glazer
- Date
- January 17, 2009
- Concert duration
- 01 hour, 44 minutes, 19 seconds, +00:39:17 longer than expected
- Venue
- Alexander Kasser Theater
- City
- Montclair, NJ , United States
- SetlistFM
- Concert setlists on SetlistFM
- Resume
- 66 Songs 2 Encores 4 Covers 9 replayed songs
- :artist next setlist
- Our Predictions
Albums Played
- They Might Be Giants: Here Come the ABCs#2 position, with 6 Songs, %9.09
- Here Come the 123s#3 position, with 6 Songs, %9.09
- Flood#4 position, with 6 Songs, %9.09
- Mink Car#5 position, with 6 Songs, %9.09
- No! (Deluxe Edition)#6 position, with 4 Songs, %6.06
- Severe Tire Damage#7 position, with 4 Songs, %6.06
- Apollo 18#8 position, with 3 Songs, %4.55
- The Else#9 position, with 3 Songs, %4.55
- The Spine#10 position, with 2 Songs, %3.03
- Factory Showroom#11 position, with 2 Songs, %3.03
- Then: The Earlier Years#12 position, with 1 Song, %1.52
- They Got Lost#13 position, with 1 Song, %1.52