- All I Ever Get for Christmas Is Blue#1 Snow Angels
- Bothered#2 Ohio
- Let It Fall#3 Blood Oranges In The Snow
Bella Luna#4 No Album- Born#5 Drunkard's Prayer
- I Don't Wanna Waste Your Time#6 The Trumpet Child
- Mary's Waltz#7 The Darkest Night of the Year
- It Came Upon the Midnight Clear#8 A Very P86 Christmas (2021 Version)Richard Storrs Willis cover
- Faithfully Dangerous#9 Good Dog Bad Dog
- If We Make It Through December#10 Blood Oranges In The SnowMerle Haggard cover
- We're Gonna Pull Through#11 Snow Angels
- Amelia's Last#12 The Darkest Night of the Year
- First Snowfall#13 Blood Oranges In The Snow
- After All We've Been Through#14 No Album
- Like a Radio#15 Till We Have Faces
- All My Favorite People#16 The Long Surrender
- I'll Be Home for Christmas (If Only in My Dreams)#17 The Beach Boys' Christmas AlbumBing Crosby cover
- The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire)#18 Christmas AlbumMel Tormé cover
- Here It Is#19 Snow AngelsEncore 1
- All I Need Is Everything#20 Good Dog Bad DogEncore 1
- Latter Days#21 Good Dog Bad DogEncore 1
Concert Resume
- Artist
- Over the Rhine
- Covers
- Bing Crosby, Mel Tormé, Merle Haggard and Richard Storrs Willis
- Date
- December 2, 2023
- Concert duration
- 01 hour, 24 minutes, 58 seconds, +00:19:04 longer than expected
- Venue
- Calvin University
- SetlistFM
- Concert setlists on SetlistFM
- Next Setlist
- Our Predictions
Albums Played
- Snow Angels#1 position, with 3 Songs, %14.29
- Blood Oranges In The Snow#2 position, with 3 Songs, %14.29
- Good Dog Bad Dog#3 position, with 3 Songs, %14.29
- The Darkest Night of the Year#5 position, with 2 Songs, %9.52
- Ohio#6 position, with 1 Song, %4.76
- Drunkard's Prayer#7 position, with 1 Song, %4.76
- The Trumpet Child#8 position, with 1 Song, %4.76
- A Very P86 Christmas (2021 Version)#9 position, with 1 Song, %4.76
- Till We Have Faces#10 position, with 1 Song, %4.76
- The Long Surrender#11 position, with 1 Song, %4.76
- The Beach Boys' Christmas Album#12 position, with 1 Song, %4.76
- Christmas Album#13 position, with 1 Song, %4.76