- Lullabye#1 Patience
- Silent Night#2 The Darkest Night of the YearJoseph Mohr & Franz Gruber cover
- Poughkeepsie#3 Good Dog Bad Dog
Little Blue River#4 No Album- Circle of Quiet#5 Patience
- Mary's Waltz#6 The Darkest Night of the Year
- Willoughby#7 Good Dog Bad Dog
- Someone I Used to Know#8 No Album
- Merry Go Round#9 No AlbumTerri Templeton cover
- Angels We Have Heard on High#10 Warmer In The Winter (Deluxe Edition)[traditional] cover
- Please Father Christmas#11 No Album
- Latter Days#12 Good Dog Bad Dog
- Bothered#13 Ohio
Concert Resume
- Artist
- Over the Rhine
- Date
- December 14, 1995
- Concert duration
- 39 minutes, 55 seconds, -00:27:22 shorter than expected
- SetlistFM
- Concert setlists on SetlistFM
- Resume
- 13 Songs 3 Covers
- Over the Rhine next setlist
- Our Predictions