- Alas#1 The Other Shore
- Space#2 The Other Shore
- Strange Eyes#3 Big Dark Love
- The Curse of Elkhart#4 Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon
- '52 Ford#5 Red of Tooth and Claw
- Last Night on Earth#6 The Other Shore
- Lost River#7 Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon
- Ghost Fields#8 Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon
Pizza Party! (at Gloria Estefan's House)#9 No Album- Stone#10 The Other Shore
- Steal Away#11 Red of Tooth and Claw
- Foxglove#12 Good Morning, Magpie
- True Dark#13 The Other Shore
- Shiola#14 In Bocca Al Lupo
- Brother#15 In Bocca Al Lupo
- Until Morale Improves, the Beatings Will Continue#16 Who Will Survive, and What Will Be Left of Them?
- Dynamite Mine#17 In Bocca Al Lupo
- The Devil in Mexico#18 Who Will Survive, and What Will Be Left of Them?
- I Came Around#19 Bitter Drink, Bitter MoonEncore 1
Concert Resume
- Artist
- Murder by Death
- Date
- May 7, 2019
- Concert duration
- 01 hour, 09 minutes, 05 seconds, -00:07:01 shorter than expected
- Venue
- New Brookland Tavern
- Address
- 122 State St, West Columbia, SC 29169, United States
- SetlistFM
- Concert setlists on SetlistFM
- Resume
- 19 Songs 1 Encore
- Murder by Death next setlist
- Our Predictions
Albums Played
- The Other Shore#1 position, with 5 Songs, %26.32
- Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon#2 position, with 4 Songs, %21.05
- In Bocca Al Lupo#3 position, with 3 Songs, %15.79
- Red of Tooth and Claw#4 position, with 2 Songs, %10.53
- Who Will Survive, and What Will Be Left of Them?#5 position, with 2 Songs, %10.53
- Big Dark Love#6 position, with 1 Song, %5.26
- Good Morning, Magpie#8 position, with 1 Song, %5.26