- Kentucky Bourbon#1 Good Morning, Magpie
- As Long as There Is Whiskey in the World#2 Good Morning, Magpie
- You Don't Miss Twice (When You're Shavin' With a Knife)#3 Good Morning, Magpie
- Steal Away#4 Red of Tooth and Claw
- Foxglove#5 Good Morning, Magpie
- King of the Gutters, Prince of the Dogs#6 Good Morning, Magpie
- Fuego!#7 Red of Tooth and Claw
- Lost River#8 Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon
- Straight at the Sun#9 Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon
- Sometimes the Line Walks You#10 In Bocca Al Lupo
- Rumbrave#11 Red of Tooth and Claw
- I Came Around#12 Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon
- The Curse of Elkhart#13 Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon
- White Noise#14 Good Morning, Magpie
- Shiola#15 In Bocca Al Lupo
- Brother#16 In Bocca Al Lupo
- Until Morale Improves, the Beatings Will Continue#17 Who Will Survive, and What Will Be Left of Them?
- Ramblin'#18 Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon
- I'm Afraid of Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf#19 Like the Exorcist, but More Breakdancing
- Spring Break 1899#20 Red of Tooth and Claw
- Comin' Home#21 Red of Tooth and Claw
- Dynamite Mine#22 In Bocca Al LupoEncore 1
- Three Men Hanging#23 Who Will Survive, and What Will Be Left of Them?Encore 1
- Those Who Stayed#24 Like the Exorcist, but More BreakdancingEncore 1
Concert Resume
- Artist
- Murder by Death
- Date
- December 30, 2011
- Concert duration
- 01 hour, 26 minutes, 46 seconds, +00:10:40 longer than expected
- Venue
- Subterranean
- Address
- 2011 W North Ave, Chicago, IL 60647, United States
- City
- Chicago, IL , United States
- SetlistFM
- Concert setlists on SetlistFM
- Resume
- 24 Songs 1 Encore
- Murder by Death next setlist
- Our Predictions
Albums Played
- Good Morning, Magpie#1 position, with 6 Songs, %25
- Red of Tooth and Claw#2 position, with 5 Songs, %20.83
- Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon#3 position, with 5 Songs, %20.83
- In Bocca Al Lupo#4 position, with 4 Songs, %16.67
- Who Will Survive, and What Will Be Left of Them?#5 position, with 2 Songs, %8.33
- Like the Exorcist, but More Breakdancing#6 position, with 2 Songs, %8.33