- Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway)#1 The Stranger (Legacy Edition)
- Joy to the World#2 Merry ChristmasIsaac Watts cover
- My Life#3 52nd Street
- The Downeaster "Alexa"#4 Live Through the Years
- Jingle Bells#5 Feliz NavidadJames Lord Pierpont cover
- Vienna#6 The Stranger (Legacy Edition)
- Deck the Halls#7 A Pentatonix Christmas Deluxe[traditional] cover
- Zanzibar#8 52nd Street
- Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer#9 Rocky Mountain ChristmasGene Autry cover
- Start Me Up#10 Tattoo You (2009 Re-Mastered)The Rolling Stones cover
- An Innocent Man#11 An Innocent Man
- Barbara Ann#12 Beach Boys Party! (Remastered)The Regents cover
- The Lion Sleeps Tonight#13 The Mavericks CollectionSolomon Linda's Original Evening Birds cover
- The Longest Time#14 An Innocent Man
- Silent Night#15 Merry ChristmasJoseph Mohr & Franz Gruber cover
- Sleigh Ride#16 That's Christmas To Me (Deluxe Edition)Leroy Anderson & His Pops Orchestra cover
- She's Always a Woman#17 The Stranger (Legacy Edition)
- Angels We Have Heard on High#18 Warmer In The Winter (Deluxe Edition)[traditional] cover
- Don't Ask Me Why#19 Glass Houses
- New York State of Mind#20 The Stranger (Legacy Edition)
- Movin' Out (Anthony's Song)#21 The Stranger (Legacy Edition)
- Pump It Up#22 This Year's ModelElvis Costello & The Attractions cover With Elvis Costello
- Allentown#23 The Nylon CurtainWith Elvis Costello
- Hark! The Herald Angels Sing#24 That's Christmas To Me (Deluxe Edition)Felix Mendelssohn cover
- Only the Good Die Young#25 The Stranger (Legacy Edition)
- Sometimes a Fantasy#26 Glass Houses
- The River of Dreams#27 River Of Dreams
- Nessun dorma#28 Renaissance (Boxset)Giacomo Puccini cover
- Scenes From an Italian Restaurant#29 The Stranger (Legacy Edition)
- Piano Man#30 Piano Man (Legacy Edition)
- We Didn't Start the Fire#31 Storm FrontEncore 1
- Uptown Girl#32 An Innocent ManEncore 1
- It's Still Rock and Roll to Me#33 Glass HousesEncore 1
- Big Shot#34 52nd StreetEncore 1
- You May Be Right#35 Glass HousesEncore 1
Concert Resume
- Artist
- Billy Joel
- Played with
- Elvis Costello
- Special guests
- Elvis Costello
- Covers
- [traditional], Elvis Costello & The Attractions, Felix Mendelssohn, Gene Autry, Giacomo Puccini, Isaac Watts, James Lord Pierpont, Joseph Mohr & Franz Gruber, Leroy Anderson & His Pops Orchestra, Solomon Linda's Original Evening Birds, The Regents and The Rolling Stones
- Date
- December 19, 2023
- Concert duration
- 02 hours, 20 minutes, 04 seconds, +00:32:22 longer than expected
- Venue
- Madison Square Garden
- Address
- 4 Pennsylvania Plaza, New York, NY 10001, United States
- City
- New York, NY , United States
- SetlistFM
- Concert setlists on SetlistFM
- :artist next setlist
- Our Predictions
Albums Played
- The Stranger (Legacy Edition)#1 position, with 7 Songs, %20
- Glass Houses#2 position, with 4 Songs, %11.43
- 52nd Street#3 position, with 3 Songs, %8.57
- An Innocent Man#4 position, with 3 Songs, %8.57
- Merry Christmas#5 position, with 2 Songs, %5.71
- That's Christmas To Me (Deluxe Edition)#6 position, with 2 Songs, %5.71
- Live Through the Years#7 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- Feliz Navidad#8 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- A Pentatonix Christmas Deluxe#9 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- Rocky Mountain Christmas#10 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- Tattoo You (2009 Re-Mastered)#11 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- Beach Boys Party! (Remastered)#12 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- The Mavericks Collection#13 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- Warmer In The Winter (Deluxe Edition)#14 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- This Year's Model#15 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- The Nylon Curtain#16 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- River Of Dreams#17 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- Renaissance (Boxset)#18 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- Piano Man (Legacy Edition)#19 position, with 1 Song, %2.86
- Storm Front#20 position, with 1 Song, %2.86